VW Vortex - Volkswagen Forum banner

1 - 20 of 20 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,564 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
As much as I am considering getting out of firearms since I find myself with no time to go hunting, or to the range.... I am seriously tempted to build one of the useless AR-15 pistols.

Seeing barreled uppers from PSA for like $200



"PSA Stealth 7" Pistol-length 5.56 1:7 Nitride 9" Lightweight Keymod Rail w/ KAK Flash Can, BCG, & CH"

along with stripped lowers etc... heck I have more fun building them.

These things have minimal use, target shooting is out the window, accuracy of a storm trooper, overpenetrating rounds useless for short barrels and home defense...

Talk me out of this before I start making a list.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,124 Posts
As much as I am considering getting out of firearms since I find myself with no time to go hunting, or to the range.... I am seriously tempted to build one of the useless AR-15 pistol.
"PSA Stealth 7" Pistol-length 5.56 1:7 Nitride 9" Lightweight Keymod Rail w/ KAK Flash Can, BCG, & CH"
Here's a few reasons to not build an AR pistol/use this pistol upper:
1. It's an AR pistol; nothing more needs to be said, but I'll go on.
2. It's from PSA- you filthy hobby-tier casual.
3. It's got Keymod; USSOCOM found M-LOK did better in testing. Not only are you a hobby-tier casual, but you're a low-speed, high-drag one.
4. KAK Flash Can? John Noveske is rolling in his grave and calling you a plebe.

:laugh: AR pistols seem like a hoodrat SBR or range gimmick. If you want to throw away $200, get the Hi-Point with factory money hydro-dip and spend the rest on nails and wood and use it to build a deck.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,551 Posts
I find building pistol ar's are better than sbr's. Don't get me wrong. I love my sbr but it's a hassle if you ever wanted to travel across state lines with it. With a pistol build and a chl you can go into any state that accepts your permit without a problem. Especially now that the atf cleared up the whole shouldering aspect my mk18 sbr shoots the same as my pistol ar.

I'd much rather have my sbr or pistol for a home defense rifle than my 16" or 18" rifles.

I also wouldn't let the internet dissuade you into thinking short barrels equal crap accuracy. When you get into 8" territory you are sacrificing accuracy but a 10" barrel I can still make easy follow up shots at 2-300 yards. A 8" barrel is still going to be accurate in home defense situations.

For myself it's worth it. I go shooting with my friends in Oregon all the time and I don't even bother taking my mk18 anymore, I just take my pistol lower and put my mk18 upper on it when I go shooting across state lines with them. Just my .02 but I have an addiction and I am constantly buying new crap all the time.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,564 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
Dear sir I say, I take you advice and I contest it!

But overall yes, it's not a smart idea. Just very tempted, but won't be doing anything.

Although the last upper I bought from PSA hasn't been bad at all. Just got it long enough before the whole MLOK/Keymod thing was ... settled? But it's a Recce styled build, so there's like zippy accessories needed. Probably just going to sell it anyways sooner than later.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,564 Posts
Discussion Starter #5
I find building pistol ar's are better than sbr's. Don't get me wrong. I love my sbr but it's a hassle if you ever wanted to travel across state lines with it. With a pistol build and a chl you can go into any state that accepts your permit without a problem. Especially now that the atf cleared up the whole shouldering aspect my mk18 sbr shoots the same as my pistol ar.
That's the other issue, I may be leaving WV in the next 6 months, and the next state laws would probably pose an issue. HD I'm already setup, until my kids can get their hands on my revolver or my 1911, which will be more of an issue in a couple years (only 4 and 2 now) and can open locked cases.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,124 Posts
Dear sir I say, I take you advice and I contest it!

But overall yes, it's not a smart idea. Just very tempted, but won't be doing anything.

Although the last upper I bought from PSA hasn't been bad at all. Just got it long enough before the whole MLOK/Keymod thing was ... settled? But it's a Recce styled build, so there's like zippy accessories needed. Probably just going to sell it anyways sooner than later.
I think one would be cool for the novelty factor, but that's after I've already purchased everything else I've got my eye on; that's a few firearms to go before I hit that point. My reply was just how many firearm forum tropes can I fit into one reply. :laugh:

As far as PSA: the answer really depends on who you're asking and when they made their purchase. It seems they've hit a rough patch recently, at least with their AK release, but FN makes their barrels and there are only so many forges that produce upper/lower receivers. If you know who makes the products they put their name on, judge off of that.
 

·
Registered
2018 Atlas R-Line; 2019 330xi M-Sport
Joined
·
32,645 Posts
AR pistols are only good for one thing... Letting you "use" your firearm while you wait twelve months for the ATF to process your Form 1 to "make" an SBR. Braces are stupid and trashy. And, it's not difficult to travel across state lines. Just file a 5030.20 a month or so before you want to go somewhere, the form is good for a year. Considering every range I go to is just on the other side of the border in WV, I have a LOT of experience with this.

Also:
- 5.56 uppers shouldn't be shorter than 10.3" at the very least.
- Short AR uppers (8" or so) should be 300BLK and that's it.


I know nothing of PSA quality as I tend to either buy from a place like BCM or assemble my own using higher end parts. That being said, I was looking at their wannabe Mk18 10.5" upper just for s***s and giggles. It's stupid cheap and I'll have a high quality BCG to throw in it. I guess the biggest concern is if they drilled the gas port properly.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,124 Posts
I know nothing of PSA quality as I tend to either buy from a place like BCM or assemble my own using higher end parts. That being said, I was looking at their wannabe Mk18 10.5" upper just for s***s and giggles. It's stupid cheap and I'll have a high quality BCG to throw in it. I guess the biggest concern is if they drilled the gas port properly.
I'm not sure if their FN barrels have the gas port already dri;;ed or if they do it in-house; if FN does it, I'd be pretty confident it was good to go.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,564 Posts
Discussion Starter #10
AR pistols are only good for one thing... Letting you "use" your firearm while you wait twelve months for the ATF to process your Form 1 to "make" an SBR. Braces are stupid and trashy. And, it's not difficult to travel across state lines. Just file a 5030.20 a month or so before you want to go somewhere, the form is good for a year. Considering every range I go to is just on the other side of the border in WV, I have a LOT of experience with this.

Also:
- 5.56 uppers shouldn't be shorter than 10.3" at the very least.
- Short AR uppers (8" or so) should be 300BLK and that's it.


I know nothing of PSA quality as I tend to either buy from a place like BCM or assemble my own using higher end parts. That being said, I was looking at their wannabe Mk18 10.5" upper just for s***s and giggles. It's stupid cheap and I'll have a high quality BCG to throw in it. I guess the biggest concern is if they drilled the gas port properly.

Noted. I always figured an AR pistol would be good for a spray n pray scenario which no one would ever encounter unless there actually is a zombie apocalypse. But the hold-over while waiting for SBR paperwork makes sense too.

Seems less and less like an idea that I need to flesh out at all. Probably better time/money spent getting a can setup for my main rifle.
 

·
Learning New Things Every Day.
'12 Earth F**ker '12 A4q '18 Q3
Joined
·
17,761 Posts
As much as I am considering getting out of firearms since I find myself with no time to go hunting, or to the range.... I am seriously tempted to build one of the useless AR-15 pistols.

Seeing barreled uppers from PSA for like $200



"PSA Stealth 7" Pistol-length 5.56 1:7 Nitride 9" Lightweight Keymod Rail w/ KAK Flash Can, BCG, & CH"

along with stripped lowers etc... heck I have more fun building them.

These things have minimal use, target shooting is out the window, accuracy of a storm trooper, overpenetrating rounds useless for short barrels and home defense...

Talk me out of this before I start making a list.
Guns are fun, mkay? If you are not a prohibited person from owning firearms, I say do whatever you want. It's a fun exercise to build something.

Also:
- 5.56 uppers shouldn't be shorter than 10.3" at the very least.
- Short AR uppers (8" or so) should be 300BLK and that's it.
Interesting. I have not heard of this before, can you explain the reasoning? I haven't looked into building an SBR/AR-P yet (I'm still trying to build my first ARs) and I haven't heard anyone on the 'nutjobforum.com' mention this. Is it something to do with ballistics difference between 5.56 and .300? Accuracy? Or wear & tear on the rifle?
 

·
Registered
2018 Atlas R-Line; 2019 330xi M-Sport
Joined
·
32,645 Posts
I've always heard/read that 5.56 needs at least 10" of full powder burn to maintain ballistics. Anything shorter can lead to gas problems and impaired ballistics.

300BLK was designed for short barrels (8"-10") as it uses a faster burning powder. Anything greater than 10" is just wasted space.
 

·
Learning New Things Every Day.
'12 Earth F**ker '12 A4q '18 Q3
Joined
·
17,761 Posts
I've always heard/read that 5.56 needs at least 10" of full powder burn to maintain ballistics. Anything shorter can lead to gas problems and impaired ballistics.

300BLK was designed for short barrels (8"-10") as it uses a faster burning powder. Anything greater than 10" is just wasted space.
So the 300BLK is the Nissan GT-R of the bullet world? :laugh:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,124 Posts
Do they use FNH barrels on all of their uppers? If so, I guess I'd be okay with their "Mk18" then.
Not sure if it's all of them, I know their product lines have expanded a lot since I last ordered from them. If the barrel description says something like "machine gun steel" or "double-thickness chrome lining", those are signs it's a FN barrel. Those are their two big talking points for their barrels.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,218 Posts
FV-QR

You could always just register it as a pistol, then put a stock on it???



































I'm kidding. :laugh:

 

·
Learning New Things Every Day.
'12 Earth F**ker '12 A4q '18 Q3
Joined
·
17,761 Posts
You could always just register it as a pistol, then put a stock on it???



































I'm kidding. :laugh:

what is this word you speak of?

:laugh:

WA handgun registry here. :banghead:
 

·
Learning New Things Every Day.
'12 Earth F**ker '12 A4q '18 Q3
Joined
·
17,761 Posts
1 - 20 of 20 Posts
Top