Just read this thread and a few others. I am 72 years old and looking for a smaller vehicle than my Sienna or the Atlas but why oh why do they (VW) think small means slow and crappy much like my ole carcuss. At any rate it seems that VW goes above and beyond to code their ECU's so that they cannot be played with. Do you think they know that it is costing them sales. I want the Tiguan but think I am going to be stuck with the new Mazda CX-5 with the new 2.5 turbo. 250 hp and 310 lbs of TQ. Going to wait a couple weeks for tuners BUT 184 hp in a 7 passenger (quasi) is silly.
Hey Dunk50,
Stuck with the new Mazda CX-5? Don't you have a choice?
I know a lot of folks tend to beat on the Tiguan by complaining about it's "slow performance"...but I don't believe they are being fair...they need to compare apples to apples. Comparing the performance of a Tiggy to a GLI (no offence intended Tim) doesn't make much sense to me. I know it's human nature to compare something new to what you are familiar with...I'm coming from a Jetta TDI...which was great on gas and fun to drive in it's own right. I needed something bigger, with loads of great creature comforts (getting up there in age myself), but didn't want to spend too much buying it (don't want car payments for the next 5-7 years), nor something that hurt my wallet at the pump. Going with a higher-performing vehicle means premium unleaded...and may not be worth it in the long run.
Another consideration is build quality. My daughter owns a Mazda...which she enjoys...but I've never been impressed with their vehicles of late. Give me a classic Mazda B-series pickup from back in the day...those were bullet proof...great for hauling stuff...but not too practical for day to day use or comfortable for long road trips.
Don't get me wrong...I love to go fast too. Which is why I have the supercharged beast in the garage for weekends in the summer!
My advise is to test drive both....at comparable trim levels...and don't feel as though you need to be easy on it...put it to the floor if you want! You are the customer!
When I took the Tiguan out on a test drive for the first time, I mentioned to the VW salesman that it seemed a little sluggish...so he suggested I switch it from Eco to Sport mode. Which I did and I was impressed! It was plenty responsive and a joy to drive...and if I just want to putz around and save gas I have the option to switch it back to Eco mode...which is a nice feature. At the time I was comparing it to an Audi Q5, but went for the Tiguan for a bunch of reasons (some listed above). I've owned VW's for years now...and have been told I'm a bit of a 'VW fan boy'...(don't like that term)...but I've been super impressed with my Tiguan Highline (Sel Premium in the US)...my mechanic calls it an Audi with a VW badge. The best of both worlds.
Enjoy!
Jim.